by Stefan Bielinski
Hibernians or St. Andrews Society? Historically speaking, who were the early Albany Irish? And who were the early Albany Scots? Hundreds of people who meet the Colonial Albany Social History Project criteria for inclusion as city people ultimately found their roots to be in what is now Scotland, Ireland, or Northern Ireland (Ulster). Understanding them culturally first raises questions of terminology. One of the more puzzling terms for this historian is the frequently encountered reference to "the Irish" who came to the American colonies and particularly to those who visited and settled in early Albany. Like so many of the traditional words used to describe the people of colonial Albany, the term "Irish" means different things to different people. Those who said "Irish" regarding eighteenth-century Albany knew who they were talking about. Today, we certainly are less certain! For consistency and because they are more or less exclusionary, we hold that Irish referred to a Roman Catholic. Scots mostly were Presbyterians. The Colonial Albany Project approach to the so-called "Irish" is simple and direct. We seek to identify (maybe "verify" is better) the ancestral homelands of every person who lived in the city of Albany prior to the Industrial Revolution. More definitive statements about those minority groups might follow completion of a comprehensive census of all such resident individuals. The garrison soldiers who arrived after 1664 were more clearly from Catholic rather than Calvinist homes and more fittingly (to our mind) were called Irish. We have noticed that the Catholics were less willing to seek services in the most dominant and consistent Dutch Reformed church than the Scottish Presbyterians who were more comfortable with the Reformed liturgy despite the language barrier. Over the first half of the eighteenth century and particularly during the years 1713-44, newcomers of both backgrounds settled in the Albany community - although they mostly went on to so-called "greener pastures" in the more outlying parts of huge Albany County. The problem of differentiating early Albany's Scots from its Irish seems to have been more widespread during the eighteenth century and particularly after 1750. In New Netherland days, the Scots émigré - principally the Glen and Sanders families were known as Scots. By the 1670s, they were joined by Scottish minister's son Robert Livingston - perhaps the most important man to live in colonial Albany. Following the end of the Great War for Empire, British-connected land speculators and developers sought to entice new settlers with advertisements like this one from 1772 found in the collections of the Library of Congress. Chief among the clans that established roots in Albany and its hinterland were the Campbells: Scots, Scots-Irish, and Irish Catholics were even more prominent in post-Revolutionary War Albany. I find it interesting (or at least curious) that twelve property owners were named Alexander ___ according to the citywide assessment roll for 1788. Understanding the lives of Catholics and Presbyterians (and their less godfearing countrymen) in their Albany context is a longtime particular interest (not that I can't say that about every other group). My larger ambition precludes focusing on them exclusively. This exposition will make more sense in the future. Please bear with us! notes
Sources: This profile
is derived chiefly from family and community-based
resources - both of which contain material of puzzling quality.
I am beginning to compile a useful online bibliography. For openers,
see Irish
Immigrants in the Land of Canaan; Colonists
from Scotland; online version of The
Scots in America; An increasingly impressive literature on
those called the "colonial Scots" exists and merits discussion here.
Substantial and evolving resources from Three Rivers.
The state of the art regarding the colonial Irish (Catholics) appears
less impressive. The seminal work entitled Old
Irish in Albany, N.Y. was compiled by judge, scholar, and
Albany native Franklin
M. Danaher and was published in 1903. Michael J. O'Brien's works
published during the 1930s are conveniently summarized online.
But see The
New York Irish, published in 1997 - where the then most learned
scholars have a whack at the subject/problem. See online: The
Journal of the American-Irish Historical Society. See also
the in-progress: Irish
Family Histories - which strives
to be a online bibliography of related publications. Again, please
bear with us.
THE Province of New-York is the most healthy Climate in America.
Many Persons in it live to 80 or 90 Years of Age; and many sickly
People from the Carolinas, &c. come to it for the Recovery of their
Health. Few in it are troubled with Fever or Ague, which prevails
so much in the Southern Colonies. It is neither so sultry hot as
Maryland, Virginia or the Carolinas, nor so very cold as in St.
Johns, Halifax, &c. In several Winters the Snow lies but about 15
Inches deep for 9 Weeks steadfastly without Rain: Thus their Wheat
is well guarded from being froze out of Ground, and the constant
Snow affords an easy Carriage of Grain to the Market
at the City of Albany, and for fetching
home Salt, Iron, &c. from it. In the Counties of Albany, Tryon,
Charlotte, Cumberland and Gloucester of said Province thousands
of Farms are to be sold for 6 Shillings Sterling per Acre, and 6
Years given to pay the Money, or rented at Sixpence Sterling per
Acre, and a Lease for ever. The first 5 Years rent-free, only 2s.
6d. Sterling Quit-Rent, either in buying or renting the Land. If
it is desired by a Number of Families, ten thousand Acres or more
can be had in one Spot. The little Hills all over the Country are
a Shelter from the cold North-West Winds. The Water is plenty, and
as good as any in the World; a fine Spaw-Well is lately found near
Cambridge. PHILADELPHIA: Printed by JOHN DUNLAP, at the Newest Printing-Office
in Market-Street, 1772.
first opened 6/18/09; last updated 2/12/16 |